|
INDUSTRY AND POLLUTION CAMPAIGN BRIEFING SHEET THE EFFECT OF ENVIRONMENTAL OESTROGENS ON HUMANS ban should be placed on further manufacture, use and disposal of those substances implicated in damage to the hormone systems of both humans and animals.
BACKGROUND
Disturbing evidence of the trends of adverse
effects on the ability of humans to reproduce
Sexuality in humans is determined by the balance of sex hormones. There are those, such as testosterone, which have a masculinizing effect (hair growth etc.) and oestrogens, which are feminising (breast development etc.). Both ovaries and testes produce testosterone and oestrogen. Sexual differentiation into male and female occurs early in fetal development.
An important feature of the male testes is the
lining of Sertoli and Leydig cells. They play
a crucial role in the development of sperm.
Prior to puberty the Sertoli cells are able to
convert testosterone into the oestrogen.
Exposure to oestrogens in the environment
In adult women, exposure to abnormally
high levels of oestrogen can affect the
fertility of the ovaries and the efficiency of
the oviduct. It can stimulate excessive
growth of tissue in the uterus and in the
breast leading to cancer.
Cryptorchidism (Undescended testicles):
The most comprehensive study of this
symptom was carried out in the Oxford area
over the period 1984-88 [3]. The study
showed an increase of 93% in incidence over
the period for children at three months of
age.
Hypospadias (Urethral opening under the
penis): Between 1965 and 1983 the number
of cases of hypospadias has increased by 157
per cent in the UK and Wales [4]. An
increasing incidence has also been reported
in many other countries such as Sweden,
Norway, Denmark, Finland and Spain. Testicular Cancer: There has been an increase in the frequency of this problem in England and Wales of 35 per cent from 1979 to 1987 [5]. Increases have also been identified in the Nordic countries for the period 1943-1980 [6]. It is thought that this cancer is initiated by factors acting early on
in life, possibly before birth.
Cardiovascular System: Oestrogen
treatment has a clear benefit for many
post-menopausal women for whom the rates
of cardiovascular mortality drop significantly
after treatment [8].
The biological effects of xenoestrogens depends on their availability and concentration within body tissue and fluids, their functioning alongside certain proteins and their binding to oestrogen receptors. They may come from a variety of sources: as pharmaceuticals or oral contraceptives, as naturally occurring substances in foodstuffs, particularly vegetables, and as man-made chemicals present as environmental pollution.
Their effects may well be complex. Some
chemicals have been shown to have
anti-oestrogenic properties such as the
dioxin TCDD and the bioflavanoids found
widely in food..
NATURAL AND SYNTHETIC
HORMONES
Evidence of environmental pollution by the
large amounts of oestrogen excreted by
pregnant women and female animals has
been elusive.
PHYTOESTROGENS (plant derived)
These are compounds with oestrogenic
activity found naturally in edible plants such
as peas, beans, cabbage, sprouts, spinach,
grains and hops. If consumed in large
quantities there is evidence of significant
biological effects. Some phytoestrogens also
act as anti-oestrogens. Whilst there may be
adverse effects from such substances in the
diet it is probable that this is balanced by the
benefits of a high plant food diet.
ORGANOCHLORINE PESTICIDES
Whilst the use of organochlorine compounds
such as DDT, dieldrin, lindane, chlordecone
products of DDT, known as p,p'-DDE, is an
especially effective anti-androgen. Some
studies have linked DDE with lactation
failure in mothers and breast cancer.
POLYCHLORINATED BIPHENYLS
Despite decreasing use and bans on the
production of PCBs, large quantities have
been dispersed into the environment. Studies
have indicated a number of ways in which
PCBs can interfere with the human hormone
system and may be linked to breast cancer.
However, conclusive evidence has been
difficult to achieve because of the large
number of varieties (congeners) of PCBs and
the probability that effects vary between
each. Two major accidents involving PCBs
in the Far East produced abortions and low
birth weight in surviving children.
DIOXINS
This family of substances known as PCDDs
(dioxins) and PCDFs (furans) are not
commercial products but arise from
incineration and as waste products from
industry. Though the volume produced is
very low the toxicity is extremely high.
Human exposure is usually via food,
especially meat, milk and fish. Dioxins have
been shown to operate as anti-oestrogen and
to have an adverse effect even at very low
levels on the sexual behaviour and sperm
production of rats. Another study has linked
dioxins with endometriosis (abnormal
growth of uterine tissue) in monkeys.
ALKYLPHENOL
POLYETHOXYLATES (APES)
Data on the potential health effects on
humans is sparse; the main areas of concern
arise from the possible intake via drinking
water or by eating contaminated fish. APEs
are known to have weak oestrogenic
properties but may cause symptoms by
working with other pollutants in the
environment.
OTHER XENOESTROGENS
Herbicides atrazine and simazine: though
neither of these chemicals has shown
especially strong oestrogenic activity in
studies, atrazine has been linked to breast
cancer. Government studies have detected
concentrations in sea water samples around
the UK, the highest being around the
Humber and Mersey estuaries.
Fungicide vinclozolin: Kelce [10]
demonstrated that this chemical had effective
anti-androgen properties on rats causing
hypospadias, cleft phallus and other
symptoms. It was concluded that similar
effects could occur in the human fetus.
Phthalates: The phthalate DEHP is known
to be toxic and to cause cancer in animals
and may well be a hazard to humans because
of its use as a plasticiser in medical and food
packages and subsequent leaching out into
the product [11]. Occupational exposure to
high levels of phthalates has been shown to
cause miscarriages in Russian workers [12].
RELATIVE LEVELS OF OESTROGEN
INTAKE
There is an urgent need to take action to
reduce the levels of exposure in order to
protect public health. This can most
effectively be done by introducing a ban on
the production and disposal of those
chemicals that are implicated in damage to
the hormone systems of humans and animals.
We believe that action by the Government is
required to introduce such a ban and we can
point to countries such as Switzerland where
preventative action has already been taken.
REFERENCES
[1] J. Augur et al. (1995) Decline in semen quality
among fertile men in Paris during the past 20 years.
New Engl. J. Med., 332, 281-285
[2] E. Carlsen et al. (1992) Evidence for decreasing
quality of semen during past 50 years. Brit. Med. J.,
305, 609-613
[3] John Radcliffe Hospital Cryptorchidism Study
Group (1992) Cryptorchidism: a prospective study of
7500 consecutive male births, 1984-8. Arch. Dis.
Childhood, 67, 892-899
[4] WHO (1991) Congenital Malformations
Worldwide: A Report from the International
[5] On the State of The Public Health (1992) The
Annual Report of the Chief Medical Officer of the
Department of Health for the year 1993, London,
HMSO
[6] T. Hakulinen et al., (1986) Trends in cancer
incidence in the Nordic countries. A
[7] E.Feuer & L-P Wun (1992) How much of the
recent rise in breast cancer incidence can be explained
by increases in mammography utilisation? Am.
J.Epidemiol., 136, 142301436
[8] WHO (1995) Research in the menopause in the
1990s (Technical Report Series), Geneva, World
Health Organisation
[9] W.R.Kelce et al. (1995) Persistent DDT metabolite
p,p' DDE is a potent androgen receptor antagonist.
Nature, 375, 581-585
[10] W.R.Kelce et al. (1994) Environmental hormone
disruptors: evidence that vinclozolin developmental
toxicity is mediated by anti-androgenic metabolites.
Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol., 126, 276-285
[11] B.J.Davis et al. (1994) Di-(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate
supresses estradiol and ovulation in cycling rats.
Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol., 128, 216-223
[12] M.V. Aldyreva et al. (1975) The influence of
phthalate plasticizers on the generative function. Gi.
Trud. prof. Zool., 12, 25-29
OTHER READING
Warhurst, A.M. (1995) An environmental assessment
of alkylphenol ethoxylates and alkylphenol., Edinburgh,
Friends of the Earth
Medical Research Council, Institute for Environment
and Health (1995) IEH assessment on Environmental
Oestrogens: Consequences to Human Health and
Wildlife, IEH
July 1995
Published by Friends of the Earth Ltd Printed on 100% recycled paper
|