Archived press release

Pesticide Safety Advice for Children to be Withdrawn

26 March 2002

The Advisory Committee on Pesticides (ACP) is recommending that the Government withdraw long-standing safety advice aimed at reducing children's exposure to pesticides. Professor David Coggan,chairman of the committee today admitted to the BBC that it had decided to "revise the advice".

The advice, that children's fruit and vegetables should be peeled, was originally issued by theGovernment's Chief Medical Officer in 1997, following concern over small children's exposure topesticides. The recommendation, which is now routinely given by Government departments in responseto parental inquiries about pesticide residues in food, is the only practical advice currently given aboutreducing children's exposure to these potentially dangerous chemicals.

FOE has written to Ministers urging them not to abandon the advice because residues of riskypesticides - which sometimes exceeds safety levels set for children - still frequently occur in fruit andvegetables. Peeling reduces these residues, although it will not remove them completely.

The original recommendation to withdraw the advice came from the Food Standards Agency which isconcerned that "misinterpretation" of the advice could imply that "only organic fruit should be suppliedto the National School Fruit Scheme" . This Scheme aims to give all young children a free piece of fruitat school each day to increase their consumption of fresh fruit and vegetables.

Professor David Coggan told the BBC that the advice "was sensible precautionary advice at the time.There's been a lot more research conducted since, and that's resolved the uncertainty and so we areable to revise the advice."

Although the committee has gone along with the FSA's suggestion, it is unlikely to go as far as sayingthat unpeeled fruit and veg is "safe". Two papers considered by the ACP show that safety levels fortoddlers are likely to be exceeded for a range of pesticides used on fruit and vegetables.

Sandra Bell, food and farming campaigner for Friends of the Earth said
"It's appalling that the FSA and Government pesticide advisers want to abandon this important safety advice for children. Youngsters should be encouraged to eat more fruit and vegetableswithout being exposed to unnecessary health risks. Research shows the pesticide levels in ourfruit and veg sometimes exceed safety limits for children - and this puts them at risk. Some of thechemicals used in pesticides have been linked to brain damage and disruption of the hormonesystem.

"The Government should do more to reduce pesticide use, and should ensure that fruit in the National School Fruit Scheme is free of toxic residues. Until the Government can be certain that the fruit and veg that children eat is residue-free, the peeling advice must remain".

If you're a journalist looking for press information please contact the Friends of the Earth media team on 020 7566 1649.

Published by Friends of the Earth Trust