Archived press release

Meacher rewrites history too ...

11 June 2002

New analysis by Friends of the Earth has blown a hole in evidence given to a key Committee of MPs by Environment Minister Michael Meacher MP. Friends of the Earth has pointed to Mr Meacher’s flawed evidence as a further signal that he may scupper a proposed new law to improve energy efficiency policies.

Mr Meacher told the Trade and Industry Select Committee on 23 May 2002 that “there has never been a Government commitment, either by the previous Government before 1997 or by our Government since, to a 30 per cent target [for improving domestic energy efficiency].”

Yet Friends of the Earth have documented scores of occasions on which both the previous and current Governments supported such targets. FOE suspects that Mr Meacher may be trying to rewrite history in order to provide an excuse for blocking a new energy efficiency law - the Home Energy Conservation Bill.

This Bill would require the Government to have a “principal aim” of making a 30% improvement in energy efficiency by 2010. FOE backed the new law when evidence emerged that councils were falling behind the longstanding Government targets because they had no legal force.

Despite this lack of legal force, there is no doubt that both this Government and the previous Conservative administration have backed a 30% target. Evidence unearthed by FOE includes:

• The current DEFRA website lists HECA targets for England as “30% in 10-15 years from April 1996 + ‘substantial progress’ expected in 10 years” (www.defra.gov.uk/environment/energy/heca95/intro.htm)
• An official report to Parliament by John Prescott MP, on 14 April 1999, says “a 30% improvement target was deliberately set as being a demanding one.” It goes on to say the target can be met, saying “there is the potential to achieve a fraction under the 30% improvement sought by Government, within about 12 years from the 1st April 1996 deadline.”
• Two Government policy reviews - ‘Monitoring the implementation of the Home Energy Conservation Act’ (1999) and ‘Review of policy framework for local authority energy efficiency activity’ (2001) – also included the target. In the first of these, there are no less than 23 references to “the 30% improvement target.” The second review asked “How should HECA work in future? Should any changes be made to … the existing 30% target.”
• Three promises made in Parliament by the previous Conservative Government Minister that he was committed to a 30% target. For example he told MPs “At first we want to set a target of 30% for every local authority, but those who feel they have a case for exemption can talk to us” (Hansard 17.3.95 col 1197.)
• Two official “circulars” by the Conservative Government, which mentioned the target on several occasions – such as “Authorities should therefore look to identify measures which, when compared with the situation as at 1st April 1996, will lead to a 30% improvement in energy efficiency.” (DoE circular 2/96 and DoE circular 5/97).

Martyn Williams, Senior Parliamentary Campaigner for Friends of the Earth said

“Mr Meacher’s claims have no relation to reality whatever. This looks like yet another attempt by a Government minister to re-write an inconvenient piece of history. If this is a tactic to provide cover for the Government to wreck the Home Energy Conservation Bill, it will not work.

What our analysis shows is that the Government has had targets for energy conservation for the last six years. They are failing to meet them – which is why we need tougher laws, and a Government commitment to action. Mr Meacher must now give his clear backing to the Home Energy Conservation Bill.”

If you're a journalist looking for press information please contact the Friends of the Earth media team on 020 7566 1649.

Published by Friends of the Earth Trust