Archived press release

New pesticide cocktail report admits concerns

15 October 2002

The report into the ‘cocktail effect’ of mixtures of pesticides was published today by the Committee on the Toxicity of Chemicals in Food, Consumer Products and the Environment (COT). The report recommends that there must be better monitoring of people’s exposure and that mixtures of pesticides are considered in the regulatory process

Friends of the Earth criticized today’s report:

• The Committee’s conclusion that there is low risk to human health, is based on assumptions not actual evidence. It is assumed that people are exposed to low levels of pesticides, but the Committee admitted that it has no idea about levels of exposure. Not only does COT admit that it is difficult to work out exposure from food residues, it also reported that information about other routes of pesticide exposure is “extremely poor or non-existent”.
• The report accepts that there are many forms of pesticide exposure - other than through eating food - but ignores these in its assessment of risk. In fact there is the potential for high levels of cumulative exposure. As well as being found as residues in food, pesticides are used in home and garden products, pet treatments, head louse treatments, paints and carpets. Some people are exposed to pesticides at work, while bystanders can be exposed from spray drift from farms. Local authorities spray pesticides in parks and gardens.
• The Committee concludes that there is not likely to be any greater risk to pregnant women, nursing mothers and children. However, it admits that this conclusion is based on “limited information” and “despite their possible greater sensitivity”.

Sandra Bell, Pesticides Campaigner for Friends of the Earth said:
“This report uses bad science to play down risks to human health in order to justify inaction. The Committee admits that it does not know the levels of pesticides that people are exposed to in their homes, through their food and in their workplaces, yet its conclusions are based on the assumption that exposure levels are low. The report raises serious concerns about mixtures of particular pesticides but its recommendations could take decades to have any effect. Ministers must see through the flaws in this report and take immediate action to protect people’s health.”

Friends of the Earth also criticises the report for its weak recommendations. Although the Committee raises concerns about the effects of mixtures of particular groups of pesticides, such as organophosphates which work in the same way, it does not recommend reducing exposure to them. Although better monitoring is needed, testing of even the most common combination of pesticides could take decades while people continue to be exposed to potentially harmful mixtures of pesticides. More immediate action is needed.

Friends of the Earth is calling on the Government to

• phase out the most risky pesticides including organophosphate and carbamates and pesticides which have hormone disrupting effects
• research and develop alternatives to chemical pesticides to ensure that farmers have an alternative means of pest and disease control - this can be funded by a tax on pesticide products;
• introduce the substitution principle into the pesticide approvals process to ensure only the safest methods of pest control are allowed.
• Give practical advice to people on how to reduce exposure to pesticides including avoiding pesticide products around the home.

The report “Risk Assessment of Mixtures of Pesticides and Similar Substances” is available on the Food Standards Agency website www.foodstandards.gov.uk in the science section.

If you're a journalist looking for press information please contact the Friends of the Earth media team on 020 7566 1649.

Published by Friends of the Earth Trust